Imposters
I have written about my experience with scams before, but I recently came across an interesting one. In the usual email scam is an offer that is tempting, promising much, and priced accordingly. Typically, they say they came across your book and were impressed, then give a complimentary synopsis of your work as if they read it (AI summarized it for them), how they can improve your exposure, and would you like to talk about it further. It is not until the third email that they get down to pricing, catered especially for you.
The point (the ploy) is you have engaged with them in a conversation instead of responding to an impersonal, generic ad. The exchange feels more personal. The next step in developing this sort of scam is the following.
I got two emails from fellow authors, each wanting to initiate a conversation, each being curious about my writing process. Both are romance writers. I am a fantasy writer. Red flag number one.
One of them, after giving me the synopsis of my book, stated, “I’m not reaching out to pitch anything, I simply wanted to let you know that your book stood out to me and to introduce myself as a fellow author. I’d love to hear what inspired you to create a medieval fantasy world of cats and what you hope readers experience as they follow Sonny’s adventure.
If you’re open to it, I’d enjoy staying in touch and following your future projects.”
“I’m not reaching out to pitch anything…” Red flag number two.
Both exchanges followed a pattern. They commented on what I said in the previous email, basically summarizing it, then asked another question. It felt more like an interview than an exchange of ideas.
Here, in part, is one of them. “I love that! So A Vacant Throne actually grew out of stories you were making up for your children while driving. That makes the whole thing even more interesting. And Whitey, Blackly, and Dumptruck those names alone make me curious about what those early stories were like. (Summary of what I said) . . .
“Since you mentioned that world-building is probably why you write these stories, I’m curious what is it about world-building that you enjoy the most? Is it creating the places and history, or seeing how your characters interact with the world you’ve created?” (The next interview-like question).
If I asked them a question, it was either answered blandly or ignored.
Rather naturally, any talk between authors may come around to marketing. I waited for it, and in both cases it did, with suggestions of someone they used. One of them offered to put me in contact with their specialist.
Specialist. Red flag number three. In the book trade, there are proofreaders, line editors, content editors, developmental editors, and book coaches, but no specialists. Not part of the jargon.
I ceased contact when it came to the point I had expected. In both cases, there was no follow-up on their part, wondering why I had stopped corresponding.
I contacted them both through their Facebook pages. One of them did get back to me, saying, “It’s beyond annoying. I am sorry, Charles – it’s definitely not me. I get a lot of these emails too. We can’t trust any correspondence anymore.”
I am not done with my warnings. I got another email from an agent of a mid-size literary agency, inquiring about my book. Big red flag! Agents are inundated with queries. They are not out there looking for books.
I went to the agency site. There is an agent there by that name. On the home page is a warning about imposters. Their agents have a very specific email address format. Any deviation from that format is not them. I checked. Yup, not the same.
